Site Search

Get Luxury News by Email

Live the Good Life

Categories more

Sections

Other

Exploring the Differences Between Metal Roofs vs Shingles

Be the first to review this item!

Published
12/25/2024

Millions of homeowners ponder the same question every year. Should they go with a metal roof or are shingles a better option? You’re going to run into pros and cons with each roofing option. So, to make it a little easier to choose between the two, we’re comparing metal roofs versus shingles.

Comparing Metal Roofing vs. Shingles

Even a few years ago, asphalt shingles were the way to go. However, roofing trends are changing. The Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association notes that shipments of asphalt roofing shingles show around a 20% decline between 2022 and 2023. On the other hand, metal roofing materials are seeing a boost in popularity, doubling over the last four years.

What’s driving the trend in metal roofing materials? The answer depends on who you ask. Some homeowners gravitate toward metal roofing for its durability in severe weather. Others go with metal for its eco-friendly properties. When budget is a primary concern, shingles tend to win out over metal roofs. Repairing asphalt shingles can also be noticeably less expensive.

Before you go with one roofing material over the other, take a few minutes to compare their ups and downs.

Both Offer Plenty of Style Options

Both shingles and metal roofing have come a long way in design options. Along with traditional-style asphalt shingles, you can find them with scalloped edges. If you’re going for a Mediterranean look, asphalt shingles have you covered. You’re also not limited in color options. You can even mix and match different colored asphalt shingles to give your home a truly unique appearance.

Metal roofing has moved on from the traditional corrugated panels. From shaker to slate and shingle, you can find the perfect metal roofing style for just about any home. You even have a ton of color options to choose from.

Metal Roofs Are More Durable

Okay, we’re not saying your asphalt shingles are going to start blowing off every time the wind kicks up. However, extreme weather can be a problem. You also need to keep an eye out for pooling water. If a shingles breaks loose, water can form underneath the roof and even leak into your home. Now, you’re cleaning up a wet mess while also worrying about the potential dangers associated with mold and mildew forming.

Metal roofs tend to be more durable compared to shingles. It’s something to think about if the weather tends to be severe in your area.

Shingles Cost Less Upfront

Metal roofs beat out shingles in durability. This typically means you’re spending less on roofing repairs. The downside to metal roofing materials is you’re going to pay more upfront. Shingles typically run about half the cost of metal roofs. Even installation costs tend to be cheaper for shingles.

On the flip side, if your goal is to increase your home’s value. A metal roof is a better option. Some insurance companies even offer lower rates for homeowners with metal roofs.

Metal Roofs are Eco-Friendly

Eco-friendly products aren’t just a passing fad. Consumers are increasingly taking steps to support businesses and products that consider the environment. While asphalt shingles are taking steps to be a tad more sustainable, they haven’t caught up to metal roofing materials.

Metal roofs are generally made from recycled materials. This means less material is going into landfills. Metal roofs can also be energy-efficient, unlike asphalt shingles. The shiny surface helps reflect heat keeping your home cooler without having to crank down the AC. However, painting asphalt shingles a light color like white can also help boost energy efficiency.

If you’re planning on installing solar panels, metal is probably your best option. The solar panels can be easily attached to the standing seam. Attaching solar panels to shingles usually means making holes in the roof. If the solar panels shift or come loose, you may be dealing with leaks and other issues.

Your HOA May Have a Say in Your Roofing Choice

HOAs are a mixed bag. You either love the organization or you’re trying to figure out a way to get the HOA out of your neighborhood. HOAs can be a pain. The organization’s bylaws pretty much dictate what you can do with your property. Everything from your yard’s appearance to the color of your house is usually covered in the bylaws. This generally includes your roofing material.

Most HOAs are firm believers in the aesthetic benefits of shingles and may not allow metal roofs. If this sounds like your HOA, you may be stuck with shingles. However, this also doesn’t mean you can’t show your HOA the advantages of metal roofing. Who knows, maybe you’ll be the one who changes the bylaws.  

Comments