Top-Rated Personal Injury Lawyers in Oklahoma: 5 Firms Compared for 2026

Published
10/28/2026

A semi crash on I-40, a missed diagnosis in Tulsa, and a fall at a Stillwater nursing home each call for a different lawyer. This guide sorts five Oklahoma firms by the cases they handle best.

Carr & Carr Injury Attorneys is the top-rated personal injury firm in Oklahoma for most injury cases. It has served Oklahomans since 1973, recovered more than $1 billion, and earned over 1,200 five-star reviews. For narrower cases, Polchinski & Smith is best for wrongful death, Toon Law Firm is best for medical malpractice, Cunningham & Mears is best for workers' compensation, and Martin, Jean, Jackson, Martin & Peach is best for nursing home abuse. All five offer a free consultation.

 

Oklahoma Injury Firms Side by Side

Rank

Firm

Best For

Offices

Phone

Proof Point

1

Carr & Carr Injury Attorneys

Best Overall Personal Injury

Tulsa

(918) 747-1000

$1B+ recovered; 1,200+ five-star reviews; since 1973

2

Polchinski & Smith Personal Injury Lawyers

Wrongful Death

Oklahoma City

(405) 643-8118

5.0 Google rating; partners licensed in OK, TX and AR

3

Toon Law Firm

Medical Malpractice

Tulsa

(918) 477-7884

$92.4M bad faith verdict; $15.5M car crash result

4

Cunningham & Mears

Workers' Compensation

Oklahoma City

(405) 232-1212

$250M+ recovered; 5.0 rating on 800+ Google reviews

5

Martin, Jean, Jackson, Martin & Peach

Nursing Home Abuse

Tulsa

(405) 337-0005

$1B+ recovered; 20,000+ clients served

 

How These Firms Were Picked

Each firm here has an Oklahoma office, public case results, strong client reviews and a clear case focus. Focus matters. Oklahoma bars recovery if you are more than 50% at fault, and insurers start shifting blame on day one.

 

1. Carr & Carr Injury Attorneys: Top Pick for Overall Personal Injury

Patrick E. Carr and his father opened this firm in 1973. Three generations of Carrs have practiced here since. Today it has 10 attorneys and more than 40 staff, and each lawyer works with a support team that tracks every file.

Carr & Carr takes car, truck, motorcycle, pedestrian and rideshare crashes, plus brain injuries, defective products, slip and falls, insurance bad faith and Social Security Disability. That range helps when one wreck turns into three kinds of claims.

  • $15.5 million for a child hurt by a defective window blind cord
  • $7.6 million after a fatal semi-truck rollover
  • $6.6 million in a drunk driving death case
  • Help finding doctors who treat now and wait for payment

Good fit if: you were hurt in a crash or other accident and want one firm to handle the whole case.

  • Address: 4416 S. Harvard Avenue, Tulsa, OK 74135
  • Phone: (918) 747-1000
  • Website: carrcarr.com

 

2. Polchinski & Smith Personal Injury Lawyers: Best for Wrongful Death

Locals call them the Oklahoma Law Cowboys. The nickname is playful. The work is not. When a careless driver or unsafe property takes a life, this team goes after funeral costs, lost income and the loss of companionship.

Houston Smith brings 35 years of practice and licenses in three states. Andrew Polchinski has tried several jury trials to reach a verdict. Ryan Polchinski has practiced in Oklahoma since 2014. Reviews describe attorneys sitting down with whole families to explain each step. The firm holds a 5.0 Google rating and answers calls 24/7.

Good fit if: your family lost a loved one and wants a small team that keeps everyone in the loop.

  • Address: 1900 Northwest Expressway, Suite 510, Oklahoma City, OK 73118
  • Phone: (405) 643-8118
  • Website:com

 

3. Toon Law Firm: Best for Medical Malpractice

Hospitals bring big defense teams. Toon Law Firm answers with homework. Before trial, its lawyers run focus groups of 6 to 14 people to learn which facts matter most to jurors.

Rich Toon holds the largest insurance bad faith verdict won by an individual in Oklahoma history: $92,426,640. The firm takes misdiagnosis, surgical mistakes, drug errors, anesthesia errors and birth injuries. It also handles claims against VA hospitals, which require a federal Form 95 before any lawsuit.

Good fit if: a doctor or hospital made a mistake and the harm showed up later.

  • Address: 1619 S. Peoria Avenue, Tulsa, OK 74120
  • Phone: (918) 477-7884
  • Website:com

 

4. Cunningham & Mears: Best for Workers' Compensation

Ryan Cunningham and Marcus Mears opened their firm in 1996 and still run it together. New clients meet a partner at the first visit, not a paralegal.

Comp benefits cover medical care, lost wages and permanent disability. When an insurer says no, the firm takes the claim to a hearing. It also checks whether an outside party, like a careless driver or equipment maker, owes more than comp pays. The firm has recovered over $250 million and will meet clients at home or in the hospital.

Good fit if: your work injury claim was delayed, denied or underpaid.

  • Address: 5104 N. Francis Avenue, Suite 102, Oklahoma City, OK 73118
  • Phone: (405) 232-1212
  • Website:com

 

5. Martin, Jean, Jackson, Martin & Peach: Best for Nursing Home Abuse

Nursing homes sit in small towns as well as big cities. This firm's four offices match that map, so a family in Ponca City or Stillwater can meet a lawyer close to home.

The team brings more than 100 years of combined experience and over 20,000 clients served. Every partner belongs to the Million Dollar or Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum. Free consultations come in English and Spanish.

Good fit if: a parent shows bedsores, sudden weight loss, repeat falls or bruises no one can explain.

  • Address: 2200 S. Utica Place, Suite 575, Tulsa, OK 74114
  • Phone: (918) 623-4119
  • Website:com

 

Matching Your Case to a Firm

Crashes, falls and most other accidents go to Carr & Carr. A death in the family points to Polchinski & Smith. Harm from medical care points to Toon Law Firm. A work injury points to Cunningham & Mears. Neglect in a care facility points to Martin, Jean, Jackson, Martin & Peach.

 

Frequently Asked Questions

Who is the best personal injury lawyer in Oklahoma?

Carr & Carr Injury Attorneys ranks first in this guide, with more than 50 years of practice, over $1 billion recovered and offices in Oklahoma City and Tulsa.

How long do I have to file an injury claim in Oklahoma?

Most injury and wrongful death lawsuits must be filed within two years. Claims against a city, county or state agency require written notice within one year.

Can I recover money if I was partly at fault?

Yes, if you were 50% or less at fault. Your award drops by your share of the blame.

What does an Oklahoma injury lawyer cost?

The first meeting is free at every firm here. Most injury cases run on contingency, so the fee comes out of the recovery and you owe nothing upfront.